行政执法案卷信息公开的审查标准研究

A Study on the Review Criteria for the Disclosure of Information in Administrative Law Enforcement Case Files

摘要: 行政执法案卷信息公开经历了从无到有、从模糊到相对清晰的发展过程，但实践中概念解释的模糊与裁量空间的宽泛，使这一概念的边界既清晰又模糊。完善行政执法案卷信息公开审查标准，需进一步明确概念内涵与外延，厘清行政执法案卷信息公开的规范依据与法理基础，明确并细化审查标准，健全卷宗阅览权与信息公开权的制度衔接。

Abstract: The disclosure of administrative law enforcement case file information has undergone a development process from nonexistence to existence, and from ambiguity to relative clarity. However, in practice, the vague interpretation of concepts and the broad discretionary space have rendered this boundary both clear and blurred. To improve the review standards for the disclosure of administrative law enforcement case file information, it is necessary to further clarify the connotation and extension of the relevant concepts, articulate the normative basis and jurisprudential foundation for such disclosure, specify and refine the review standards, and strengthen the institutional cohesion between the right to inspect case files and the right to information disclosure.