理性与关怀:国家学校与家庭式学校教育模式的异同比较——基于《理想国》与《学会关心》
Rationality and Care: A Comparative Analysis of the Similarities and Differences between State Schooling and Home-Based Schooling Models—Based on “The Republic” and “Learning to Care”
摘要: 教育模式的构建基于对人性本质和社会理想的认知,而“理性”和“关怀”作为教育哲学的两个维度,在不同历史环境下会有不同的教育实践路径。本文以柏拉图《理想国》的“国家学校”和内尔·诺丁斯《学会关心》的“家庭式学校”为教育范式,围绕“理性”和“关怀”双重维度,从育人目标、课程设置、教学模式和教育结果四个角度分别比较异同。两种教育模式分别是以“理性优先”和“关怀本位”为核心思想来展开,柏拉图的《理想国》是典型的国家教育模式,以城邦为主,由城邦来对平民进行理性和正义的教育,而诺丁斯的《学会关心》则是以家庭教育作为教育主要形式,希望将学校教育改造成家庭交易教育的模式,以关心关系为主,为学生建立一个良好循坏的关怀圈层。但两者并非绝对对立,虽然在很多方面不相同,但是都是以“社会优化”为终极导向。
Abstract: The construction of educational models is based on the understanding of human nature and social ideals. “Rationality” and “care” are two dimensions of educational philosophy, and they will have different educational practice paths in different historical contexts. This article takes Plato’s “State School” in “The Republic” and Nel Noddings’ “School of Care” in “Learning to Care” as educational paradigms. Focusing on the dual dimensions of “rationality” and “care”, this paper compares the similarities and differences in four aspects: educational goals, curriculum design, teaching models, and educational outcomes. The two educational models are respectively developed with the core ideas of “rationality priority” and “care as the main focus”. Plato’s “The Republic” is a typical model of state education, centered on the city-state, and the city-state provides rational and just education to the common people. While Noddings’ “Learning to Care” takes family education as the main form of education, aiming to transform school education into a model of family transaction education, emphasizing the caring relationship and establishing a good circular caring circle for students. However, the two are not absolutely opposed. Although they differ in many aspects, they both aim at “social optimization” as the ultimate goal.
文章引用:孙新亚. 理性与关怀:国家学校与家庭式学校教育模式的异同比较——基于《理想国》与《学会关心》[J]. 教育进展, 2026, 16(11): 324-331. https://doi.org/10.12677/ae.2026.16112390

参考文献

[1] 孙银光, 杜时忠. 诗哲之争: 《理想国》中教育观的冲突与融合[J]. 复旦教育论坛, 2021, 19(6): 57-63.
[2] 姜丙毅. 柏拉图《理想国》中的教育思想及其当代价值[J]. 教育评论, 2024(7): 163-168.
[3] 周加仙. 学会关心: 从生物倾向到伦理关怀[J]. 教育发展研究, 2017, 37(8): 10-17.
[4] Noddings, N. (2002) Starting at Home: Caring and Social Policy. University of California Press, 220.
[5] 天龙. 学会关心: 与内尔·诺丁斯对话[J]. 全球教育展望, 2010, 39(11): 10-13.
[6] 张莉莉, 谢康. 我国义务教育投资与负担模式改革探究——《理想国》国家教育思想视角下[J]. 现代商贸工业, 2025(16): 195-197.
[7] [英]厄奈斯特·巴克. 希腊政治理论——柏拉图及其前人[M]. 卢华萍, 译. 长春: 吉林人民出版社, 2003: 254.
[8] 林伟伟. 道德教育: 以关心为“核”——读《学会关心——教育的另一种模式》有感[J]. 思想政治课教学, 2015(7): 95-96.
[9] 姚国艳. 从知识传递到生命关怀: 培养完整的人——读《学会关心: 教育的另一种模式》有感[J]. 教育视界, 2025(5): 92-96.
[10] 柏拉图. 理想国[M]. 郭斌和, 张竹明, 译. 北京: 商务印书馆, 1986.
[11] 马燕迪. 学会关心: 对中学教学价值观的反思[J]. 教育探索, 2016(6): 24-26.
[12] Stone, L. (2006) Drawing Parts Together. the Philosophy of Education of Nel Noddings. Utbildning & Demokrati—Tidskrift för Didaktik och Utbildningspolitk, 15, 13-32.
https://doi.org/10.48059/uod.v15i1.811
[13] 内尔·诺丁斯. 学会关心: 教育的另一种模式[M]. 第2版. 北京: 教育科学出版社, 2019: 33.