从“到馆”到“成效”:高职学生图书馆利用差异对学业成绩影响的实证研究
From “Library Attendance” to “Academic Outcomes”: An Empirical Study on the Impact of Library Use Differences on Academic Performance of Higher Vocational College Students
摘要: 传统图书馆评估多聚焦于“到馆率”等行为频次指标,难以准确衡量图书馆服务对学生学业发展的实际贡献。本研究基于北京某高职院校高频入馆学生的客观数据,整合图书馆门禁记录、教务成绩及奖学金信息,并辅以问卷调查,采用方差分析,实证检验不同图书馆利用行为与学业成绩、奖学金获取的关系。结果表明:不同入馆目的的学生在学业成绩上存在极显著差异,以“课程学习及学术研讨”和“自习与备考”为目的的深层利用者成绩显著优于休闲阅读、借阅图书等浅层利用者,但不同利用行为在奖学金获取上无显著差异;多因素分析显示,入馆目的对学业成绩具有稳健的主效应,且该效应在学院与性别群体中无显著异质性,性别主效应在控制其他变量后显著。研究证实图书馆利用行为对学业成绩具有“质”的区分效力,建议高职院校图书馆从“到馆率”导向转向“利用质量”导向,构建分层精准服务与常态化关联评估机制,充分发挥图书馆作为“第二课堂”的学业促进功能。
Abstract: Traditional library assessments mostly focus on behavioral frequency indicators such as “library attendance rate”, making it difficult to accurately measure the actual contribution of library services to students’ academic development. Based on objective data from high-frequency library users at a higher vocational college in Beijing, this study integrates library access control records, academic transcripts, and scholarship information, supplemented by questionnaire surveys, and employs analysis of variance to empirically examine the relationship between different library use behaviors and academic performance as well as scholarship acquisition. The results show that students with different purposes for visiting the library exhibit highly significant differences in academic performance. Deep users, whose purposes are “course learning and academic discussion” and “self-study and exam preparation”, significantly outperform shallow users whose purposes are leisure reading and book borrowing. However, no significant differences are found among different use behaviors in scholarship acquisition. Multivariate analysis reveals that the purpose of library visits has a robust main effect on academic performance, with no significant heterogeneity across college and gender groups, while the main effect of gender remains significant after controlling for other variables. The study confirms that library use behavior has a “qualitative” differentiating effect on academic performance. It is recommended that higher vocational college libraries shift from an “attendance rate” orientation to a “use quality” orientation, build tiered and precise service mechanisms along with regularized correlation assessment mechanisms, and fully leverage the library’s academic promotion function as a “second classroom”.
参考文献
|
[1]
|
宋志强. 我国高校学生图书馆焦虑及其影响因素研究[D]: [博士学位论文]. 天津: 南开大学, 2014.
|
|
[2]
|
刘敬仪, 廖宇. 高校图书馆对大学生学习成效的影响研究述评[J]. 文献与数据学报, 2021, 3(3): 3644.
|
|
[3]
|
张赛男, 刘恩涛. 图书馆资源利用与学生学业成绩的关联性实证研究——以北京科技大学为例[J]. 江苏科技信息, 2023, 40(3): 74-80.
|
|
[4]
|
Kokoç, M., Bütüner, S.Ö. and Güler, M. (2025) A Meta-Analysis on the Effect of Learning Analytics Interventions on Students’ Academic Performance. Journal of Research on Technology in Education, 58, 1355-1379. https://doi.org/10.1080/15391523.2025.2536571
|
|
[5]
|
Fitzgerald, S.R., Berube, S., Jiang, Z. and Ting, C. (2025) Library Use and Student Success: Focus on First Generation Students. New Review of Academic Librarianship, 31, 245-263. https://doi.org/10.1080/13614533.2025.2466519
|
|
[6]
|
王洪亮, 赵圆圆. 学生行为数据与学业成绩的关系研究——基于离群点检测算法[J]. 石家庄职业技术学院学报, 2023, 35(2): 35-40.
|