游戏规则不正当竞争法保护模式之反思
Reflection on the Protection Model of the Unfair Competition Law of Game Rules
摘要: 针对游戏规则的保护问题，我国司法实践发展出版权保护和反不正当竞争法保护两种模式。后者保护模式是否合理并未引起学界的足够重视。本文通过对知识产权法和反不正当竞争法的关系出发，利用额外因素法和比例原则明晰反不正当竞争法对知识产权法扩展保护的合理限度，从而分析依赖于反不正当竞争法保护游戏规则所造成的逻辑困境和法律后果。
Abstract: For the protection of game rules, China’s judicial practice has developed two models of copyright protection and anti-unfair competition law protection. Whether the latter protection model is reasonable has not attracted sufficient attention from the academic community. In this paper, by starting from the relationship between intellectual property law and anti-unfair competition law, we clarify the reasonable limits of the extended protection of intellectual property law by anti-unfair competition law using the law of additional factors and the principle of proportionality, so as to analyze the logical dilemma and legal consequences caused by relying on anti-unfair competition law to protect game rules.
文章引用：应严庆. 游戏规则不正当竞争法保护模式之反思[J]. 争议解决, 2022, 8(4): 1359-1367. https://doi.org/10.12677/DS.2022.84185

参考文献

[1] 朱艺浩. 论网络游戏规则的著作权法保护[J]. 知识产权, 2018(2): 67-76.
[2] 孔祥俊. 《民法总则》新视域下的反不正当竞争法[J]. 比较法研究, 2018(2): 92-116.
[3] 郑成思. 反不正当竞争与知识产权[J]. 法学, 1997(6): 55-60.
[4] 孔祥俊. 反不正当竞争法新原理•总论[M]. 北京: 法律出版社, 2019: 59.
[5] 王艳芳. 商业道德在反不正当竞争法中的价值与标准二重构造[J]. 知识产权, 2020(6): 3-17.
[6] 蒋舸. 关于竞争行为正当性评判泛道德化之反思[J]. 现代法学, 2013, 35(6): 85-95.
[7] Katzenbach, C., et al. (2016) Copies, Clones, and Genre Building: Discourses on Imitation and Innovation in Digital Games. International Journal of Communication, 10, 838-859.
[8] Van Roessel, L. and Katzenbach, C. (2020) Navigating the Grey Area: Game Production between Inspi-ration and Imitation. Convergence, 26, 402-420. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] 
[9] See Kur, A. (2014) What to Protect, and How? Unfair Competition, Intellectual Property, or Protection Sui Generis. In: Lee, N., et al., Eds., Intellectual Property, Unfair Competition and Publicity: Convergences and Development, Edward Elgar Publishing, Cheltenham, 11-32. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] 
[10] 卢纯昕. 反不正当竞争法在知识产权保护中适用边界的确定[J]. 法学, 2019(9): 30-42.
[11] 刘维. 论反不正当竞争法对知识产权补充保护之边界[J]. 竞争法律与政策评论, 2017, 3(1): 64-78.
[12] 王迁. 知识产权法教程[M]. 第七版. 北京: 中国人民大学出版社, 2021: 499.
[13] 孔祥俊. 论反不正当竞争法的二元法益保护谱系——基于新业态新模式新成果的观察[J]. 政法论丛, 2021(2): 3-18.
[14] Ernest Adams, Joris Dormans. 游戏机制——高级游戏设计技术[M]. 石曦, 译. 北京: 人民邮电出版社, 2014.
[15] Juul, J. (2005) Half-Real: Video Games between Real Rules and Fictional Worlds. The MIT Press, Cambridge, 58.
[16] Fabricatore, C. (2007) Gameplay and Game Mechanics Design Gameplay and Game Me-chanics Design: A Key to Quality in Videogames. Oecdceri Expert Meeting on Videogames & Education, 2007, 4-10.
[17] 胡骋. 论非传统商标的显著性认定: 价值立场与论证框架[J]. 知识产权, 2020(1): 39-50.
[18] Kon-inklijke Philips Electronics NV v. Remington Consumer Products Ltd., Court of Justice, Case C-299/99, Opinion of Advocate General Ruiz-Jarabo Colomer’s, paras. 16, 28, 30, 31, 35.
[19] 孔祥俊. 论反不正当竞争的基本范式[J]. 法学家, 2018(1): 50-67.
[20] 兰磊. 比例原则视角下的《反不正当竞争法》一般条款解释——以视频网站上广告拦截和快进是否构成不正当竞争为例[J]. 东方法学, 2015(3): 68-81.
[21] von Grafenstein, M. (2012) Copyright Protection of Formats in the European Single Market. European Legal Informatics Study Program, 7.
[22] Bechtold, S. (2013) The Fashion of TV Show Formats. Michigan State Law Review, 451, 451-512. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] 
[23] Oberlandesgericht MOnchen [OLG Mfinchen] [Munich Court of Ap-peals] Sept. 10, 1992, Case No. 6 U 2761/92, 8 Rechtsprechungs-Report 619, 1993 (Ger.).

为你推荐