海商事背景下普通法合同解释规则的脉络梳理与进路分析
The Context and Approach Analysis of the Common Law Contract Interpretation Rules under the Background of Maritime Affairs
DOI: 10.12677/DS.2023.95255, PDF,   
作者: 赵 诣:华东政法大学国际法学院,上海
关键词: 合同解释普通法海商法 Contract Interpretation Common Law Maritime Law
摘要: 不可否认海商事领域有其特殊的涉外性和专业性,但也如美国大法官斯托顿发表的关于海商事合同解释规则的观点中所说的,海商事合同的解释与其他任何类型的合同的解释没有根本上的区别。从19世纪至今,合同解释规则从最原始的以文义解释为主的传统规则,发展到20世纪末霍夫曼勋爵提出的现代规则,再发展为21世纪对传统规则的回归和对构建新规则的尝试。本文将着眼于普通法下的合同解释规则的发展脉络,结合海商事领域,梳理其演变的过程,究其演变的内在规律,尝试阐明未来海商事合同解释规则在普通法下的合理发展路径。
Abstract: It is undeniable that the field of maritime affairs has its special involvement and professionalism. However, as US Justice Staughton said in his lecture on the interpretation rules of maritime affairs contracts in New York University Law School, there is no fundamental difference between interpretation of maritime contracts and interpretation of any other kind of contract. This article will focus on the common law rules of contract interpretation of development, from the traditional rules to modern rules, to explore the new development of rules, combined with the maritime field, sort out the process of evolution, investigate its inherent law of evolution, trying to clarify the future maritime matter under the common law of contract interpretation rules and reasonable development path.
文章引用:赵诣. 海商事背景下普通法合同解释规则的脉络梳理与进路分析[J]. 争议解决, 2023, 9(5): 1887-1894. https://doi.org/10.12677/DS.2023.95255

参考文献

[1] Burton, S.J. (2009) Elements of Contract Interpretation. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 12. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef
[2] Glasser, M.K. and Rowley, K.A. (1997) On Parol: The Construction and Interpretation of Written Agreements and the Role of Extrinsic in Contract Litigation. Baylor Law Review, 49, 657.
[3] 杨良宜. 合约的解释: 规则与应用[M]. 北京: 法律出版社, 2015: 31-32.
[4] Winchester, J. (1808) Construction of Maritime Contracts. American Law Journal and Miscellaneous Rep-ertory, 1, 209-216.
[5] Rix, B. (2019) The Common Law and Civil Law Traditions of Contract Interpretation in the Context of Maritime Law. In: Özdel, M., Ed., Commercial Maritime Law, Hart Publishing, Oxford, 51-64. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef
[6] Taylor, A. (2012) Multi-Link Leisure Developments Ltd. v. North Lanarkshire Council: Commercial Interpretation or Relief from a Bad Bargain. Victoria University of Wellington Law Review, 43, 373-402. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef
[7] Eder, B. (2015) The Construction of Shipping and Marine Insur-ance Contracts: Why Is It So Difficult. 33rd Donald O’May Lecture.
[8] The Rt. Hon. Lord Justice Staughton (1995) Interpretation of Maritime Contracts. Journal of Maritime Law and Commerce, 26, 259-272.
[9] Hendrikse, M. (2015) Interpretation of Contracts in Maritime Practice: Benefits from Instruments for European Harmonisation of Private Law. European Journal of Commercial Contract Law, 7, 1-6. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef
[10] 郑易, 初北平. 商业理念在合同解释中的作用——英国最高法院“Rainy Sky v. Kookm in Bank”案评析[J]. 世界海运, 2012, 35(11): 39-46. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef
[11] Mclauchlan, D. (2015) The Lingering Confusion and Uncertainty in the Law of Contract Interpretation. Lloyd’s Maritime and Commercial Law Quarterly, 33, 406-438. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef
[12] Valcke, C. (2009) On Comparing French and English Contract Law: In-sights from Social Contract Theory. Journal of Comparative Law, 4, 69-95. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef