浅析法律与道德的冲突与融合
A Brief Analysis of the Conflict and Integration of Law and Morality
摘要: “法安天下,德润人心”,法律与道德的关系从古至今都是一对既相互融合又相互冲突的概念,无论是从西方的自然法学派和实证主义法学派还是中国古代的儒家和法家,都表现出了两者在起规范作用的过程中会出现相互协调又相互矛盾的情况。而法律和道德同为规范社会的一种手段,在实施的过程中通常会出现矛盾,我们究竟应当怎么去处理法律与道德的矛盾,也成为了摆在我们面前的一个难题,本文旨在通过对历史上法律与道德的关系的梳理,总结得出怎样做到法律与道德最大限度的平衡。
Abstract:
“Law enforces the world, and virtue moistens the hearts of men”. The relationship between law and morality has been a pair of concepts that are both integrated and conflicting from ancient times to the present, whether from the Western natural law school and the positivist legal school or the ancient Chinese Confucianism and legalism, both show that the two will coordinate and contradict each other in the process of playing a normative role. Law and morality are both a means of regulating society, there are usually contradictions in the process of implementation, how should we deal with the contradiction between law and morality, has also become a difficult problem in front of us, this article aims to sort out the relationship between law and morality in history, summarize how to achieve the maximum balance between law and morality.
参考文献
|
[1]
|
林海. 哈富论战、拉德布鲁赫公式及纳粹法制迷案——从历史视角透析理论问题[J]. 南京大学法律评论, 2008(Z1): 261-276.
|
|
[2]
|
谌洪果. 天人交战的审判: 哈特与富勒之争的再解读[J]. 法律方法与法律思维, 2007(1): 250-286.
|
|
[3]
|
孙笑侠, 麻鸣. 法律与道德: 分离后的结合——重温哈特与富勒的论战对我国法治的启示[J]. 浙江大学学报(人文社会科学版), 2007(1): 144-152.
|
|
[4]
|
范进学. 论道德法律化与法律道德化[J]. 法学评论, 1998(2): 37-44.
|
|
[5]
|
刘云林. 道德法律化的学理基础及其限度[J]. 南京师大学报(社会科学版), 2001(6): 33-38.
|
|
[6]
|
尤莉. 法律概念的问题与结构——读哈特的《法律的概念》[J]. 法律与伦理, 2020(1): 67-76.
|
|
[7]
|
马长山. 法治社会中法与道德关系及其实践把握[J]. 法学研究, 1999(1): 2-16.
|