论条约演进解释的适用完善
On the Perfection of the Application of Evolutionary Interpretation of Treaties
摘要: 鉴于条约约文固有的不周延性和抽象性,演进解释在国际条约的理解与适用中的作用愈发重要。目前演进解释的适用越来越广泛,但其在适用过程中也日益凸显出诸多问题,如演进解释的自身性质及适用规则不明确,忽略缔约国的真实意图,以及司法机构自由裁量权过大等。因此,随着时间的流逝与发展,应当对演进解释进行重新审视并对其适用予以必要限制,从而最大化的平衡条约的稳定性与变动性。
Abstract:
The role of evolutionary interpretation in the understanding and application of international treaties has become increasingly important because of the inherent incomplete and abstract nature of treaty texts. At present, the application of evolutionary interpretation has become more and more extensive, but many problems have been increasingly highlighted in the process of its application, such as the unclear nature of evolutionary interpretation and the rules of its application, ignoring the real intention of the parties, and the excessive discretion of the judiciary, and so on. Therefore, with the passage of time and development, the evolutionary interpretation should be reexamined and its application should be restricted as necessary, in order to maximize the balance between the stability and variability of the treaty.
参考文献
|
[1]
|
Wessel, J. (2004) Relational Contract Theory and Treaty Interpretation: End-Game Treaties v. Dynamic Obligations. NYU Annual Survey of American Law, 60, 176-180.
|
|
[2]
|
孙南翔. 论“发展的条约解释”及其在世贸组织争端解决中的适用[J]. 环球法律评论, 2015(5): 165-173.
|
|
[3]
|
吴卡. 国际条约演化解释理论与实践[M]. 北京: 法律出版社, 2016: 30, 165, 191-202.
|
|
[4]
|
Nolte, G. (2023) First Report on Subsequent Agreements and Subsequent Practice in Relation to the Interpretation of Treaties. https://legal.un.org/ilc/documentation/english/a_cn4_660.pdf
|
|
[5]
|
韩逸畴. 时间流逝对条约解释的影响——论条约演进解释的兴起、适用及其限制[J]. 现代法学, 2015(6): 149-150.
|
|
[6]
|
Sonnleitner, L. (2019) The Democratic Legitimacy of Evolutive Interpretation by the European Court of Human Rights. Temple In-ternational & Comparative Law Journal, 33, 279-297.
|
|
[7]
|
Arato, J. (2010) Subsequent Practice and Evolutive Inter-pretation: Techniques of Treaty Interpretation over Time and Their Diverse Consequences. Law & Practice of Interna-tional Courts and Tribunals, 9, 443-494. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
|
|
[8]
|
刘雪红. 论条约演化解释对国家同意原则的冲击[J]. 法律科学, 2017(3): 65-70.
|
|
[9]
|
刘宁元, 闫飞. 条约演化解释方法之缔约方意图推定[J]. 北华大学学报, 2020(3): 83.
|
|
[10]
|
Herdegen, M. (2023) Interpretation in International Law.
https://opil.ouplaw.com/display/10.1093/law:epil/9780199231690/law-9780199231690-e723
|
|
[11]
|
International Law Commission (2023) Report on the Work of Its 65th Session.
https://legal.un.org/ilc/reports/2013/chinese/chp4.pdf
|
|
[12]
|
曾令良. 从“中美出版物市场准入案”上诉机构裁决看条约解释的新趋势[J]. 法学, 2010(8): 17.
|
|
[13]
|
李浩培. 条约法概论[M]. 北京: 法律出版社, 2003: 361.
|
|
[14]
|
邢爱芬, 韩容. 条约演化解释证成及其适用价值[J]. 学理论, 2020(1): 69-72.
|
|
[15]
|
United Nations. Yearbook of the International Law Commission 1966. (A/CN.4/SER.A/1966).
https://legal.un.org/ilc/publications/yearbooks/english/ilc_1996_v1.pdf
|
|
[16]
|
吴卡. 条约演化解释方法的最新实践及其反思[J]. 法学家, 2012(1): 163-165.
|
|
[17]
|
Ross, S.F. (2023) The Location and Limits of Dynamic Statutory In-terpretation in Modern Judicial Reasoning.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/40823651_The_Location_and_Limits_of_Dynamic_Statutory_Interpretation_in_Modern_Judicial_Reasoning
|
|
[18]
|
邢爱芬. 条约演化解释的适用与发展研究——以欧洲人权法院为例[J]. 中国政法大学学报, 2020(2): 167.
|