代孕行为中亲子关系的法律规制研究
Legal Regulation of Parent-Child Relationship in Surrogacy
DOI: 10.12677/DS.2021.71003, PDF,   
作者: 颉永智:重庆邮电大学,重庆
关键词: 代孕私权亲子关系 Surrogacy Private Rights Parent-Child Relationship
摘要: 随着科技的快速发展,人类的社会生活也发生了诸多变化。人工辅助生育技术是现代科学技术的一项成果,人工辅助生育技术为患有不孕不育病症的夫妻带来了生育的希望,但是人工辅助生育类别下的代孕技术也带来了极大的争议。代孕行为中委托人和代孕母亲与代孕子女的关系不同于传统的伦理关系,代孕行为是对社会伦理制度极大的挑战。尽管代孕行为为我国法律所禁止,但是代孕子女的成功生育,意味着该代孕行为生育的子女享有一系列的人身权利,法律应该为其健康成长提供制度保障。如何认定代孕行为中的亲子关系成了亟待解决的社会问题,但是现有的理论学说争议不一,甚至现有的法院判决也有不一致的情形。因此,调整代孕子女出生后亲子关系的法律规制的构建至关重要。
Abstract: With the rapid development of science and technology, many changes have taken place in human social life. Artificial assisted reproductive technology is an achievement of modern science and technology. Artificial assisted reproductive technology brings hope for couples with infertility, but surrogacy technology under artificial assisted reproductive category also brings great controversy. In surrogacy, the relationship between client, surrogate mother and surrogate child is different from the traditional ethical relationship. Surrogacy is a great challenge to the social ethical system. Although surrogacy is prohibited by Chinese law, the successful birth of surrogate children means that the children born by surrogacy enjoy a series of personal rights, and the law should provide institutional guarantee for their healthy growth. How to identify the parent-child relationship in surrogacy has become a social problem to be solved, but the existing theories and theories are controversial, and even the existing court decisions are inconsistent. Therefore, it is very important to adjust the legal regulation of surrogate children’s parentage.
文章引用:颉永智. 代孕行为中亲子关系的法律规制研究[J]. 争议解决, 2021, 7(1): 16-26. https://doi.org/10.12677/DS.2021.71003

参考文献

[1] 卫生部关于印发人类辅助生殖技术与人类精子库评审、审核和审批管理程序的通知[EB/OL].
http://www.nhc.gov.cn/bgt/pw10303/200708/6998a89f66c247469a179482dd9f930c.shtml, 2007-08-14.
[2] 杨遂全, 钟凯. 从特殊群体生育权看代孕部分合法化[J]. 社会科学研究, 2012(3): 77-83.
[3] 杨立新. 适当放开代孕禁止与满足合法代孕正当要求——对“全国首例人体冷冻胚胎权属纠纷案”后续法律问题的探讨[J]. 法律适用, 2016(7): 38-42.
[4] 纽约时报揭中国代孕黑市: 代孕母亲供不应求[Z/OL].
https://china.cankaoxiaoxi.com/2014/0817/463621.shtml, 2012-08-13.
[5] Elrod, L.D. (2010) National and Inter-national Momentum Builds for More Child Focus in Relocation Disputes. Family Law Quarterly, 44, 341-371, 373-374.
[6] 侯卫青. 代孕子女监护权纠纷中的利益衡量及法律路径选择——以全国首例代孕子女监护权纠纷案为例[J]. 青少年犯罪问题, 2017(1): 5-14.
[7] Elrod, L.D. and Spector, R.G. (2011) A Review of the Year in Family Law: Working toward More Uniformity in Laws Relating to Families. Family Law Quarterly, 44, 469-518.
[8] 朱晓峰. 非法代孕与未成年人最大利益原则的实现——全国首例非法代孕监护权纠纷案评释[J]. 清华法学, 2017(1): 120-133.
[9] 费小兵, 陈进. 国内首例代孕所致监护权案引发的代孕合法性反思——基于中华法之道与西方相关哲学的多维视域[J]. 民间法, 2019, 23(1): 136-159.